All journal entries

Can punctuation change an invitation?

Use a spoken exchange to explore how a question mark changes what a listener expects.

A page of writing from Travelling Pages
Photograph from the Samskaara school archive

Write “You are coming with us.” on one strip and “You are coming with us?” on another. Give the strips to two pretend speakers waiting for a bus. Read each aloud and invite the listener to reply naturally. One speaker seems to be telling the listener something, while the other is checking a possibility.

Draw the replies underneath. The listener might pack a bag after the statement or say “Are you sure?” after the question. Try rewriting the second strip as “Are you coming with us?” Both versions ask a question, but the speakers may sound differently surprised. Read the exchange in a familiar home language too and listen for the changes in wording or voice.